Re: Taxonomy draft - web replication problems

From: Wojtek Sylwestrzak (W.Sylwestrzak@icm.edu.pl)
Date: Fri Aug 20 1999 - 10:17:53 MDT


Gary Tomlinson wrote:

>
> We need to complete and deliver the 3 comitted RFCs in order to apply for an expanded charter to do forward looking work. I appreciate your comments made on 8/15 regarding replication. Lets all work these into our current taxonomy and improve the definition and accuracy of replication currently employed broadly in the web today.
>
> Gary
>

To start with, what confuses me is the relation of 'replication' and
'caching'.
I think the taxonomy draft is the place to specify this.

Is caching just a special case of replication or are these terms
exlusive ?

My understnding is that both mirroring and caching are various means of
replication,
but some people, notably the I2-DSI, tend to understand that replication
is more
a synonym of mirroring with caching being something other. There was no
problem
until we spok of caching and mirroring, but then came 'replication' ...

my vague definition would be:

replication = distribution of data to remote locations in order to
localize traffic

caching = on-demand replication of individual files

mirroring = permanent replication of complete data packages

and my question is:
shall we move along these lines, or does this make no sense at all.

Gary ?

--w



This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu Nov 18 2004 - 11:21:26 MST